Not Woke Shows
Find a mistake?

MOVIE · 2023

The Little Mermaid IS WOKE

—
—/10Community rating
Label itIS WOKE0

The youngest of King Triton’s daughters, and the most defiant, Ariel longs to find out more about the world beyond the sea, and while visiting the surface, falls for the dashing Prince Eric.

With mermaids forbidden to interact with humans, Ariel makes a deal with the evil sea witch, Ursula, which gives her a chance to experience life on land, but ultimately places her life – and her father’s crown – in jeopardy.

Oops! Is this show WOKE?

Only an account holder or member can file. Cite a scene, a line, or a pattern. Other account holders +1 or −1 that argument, once each. The show is not IS WOKE until enough of them have given a +1. Enough −1s remove the write-up, and it is no longer shown.

Sign in to file a woke label. One of each criterion per member.

Comments and reviews

  • Lila Marsh

    Member review

    Lila Marsh

    Sep 20, 2026

    7/10

    I went into The Little Mermaid expecting the usual Disney live-action mixed bag and came out thinking it landed better than most of the recent ones. Halle Bailey carries a lot of it with her take on Ariel. Her version of Part of Your World lands with real feeling, and the way she sells the curiosity and longing feels natural instead of forced. The rest of the cast holds up too. Javier Bardem brings some weight to Triton without overdoing the stern father bit, and Daveed Diggs makes Sebastian work even with the added lines. Melissa McCarthy as Ursula is hit or miss for me. She has presence, but the whole look and some of the delivery felt off from what I remembered of the original. Awkwafina’s Scuttle actually ended up being one of the brighter spots, giving the comic relief a fresh energy that didn’t grate. Visually the movie splits pretty evenly between the ocean and the surface. The underwater sequences have a nice sense of space and movement, and the land scenes keep things grounded without looking flat. That balance helped the story feel like it was moving between two real places instead of just switching filters. The songs mostly translate, though a couple of the big group numbers stretch out longer than they need to and lose some snap. The runtime shows in spots. A few scenes could have been trimmed without losing anything important. The casting drew plenty of talk before release, but once the movie started it didn’t get in the way of the story for me. It stayed close enough to the 1989 version in tone and structure that the core beats still worked. Eric and Ariel’s connection gets a little more room to breathe than in the cartoon, which helps the deadline feel like actual stakes instead of just a plot device. There are still the usual remake stretches where things slow down to add extra emotion or side business, but they don’t sink the whole thing. I’m not someone who lines up for every Disney redo, yet this one felt worth the time. It doesn’t top the animated original for me, but it sits comfortably alongside it as a solid retelling rather than a pale copy. Three and a half stars feels right. That said, the middle hour is where the extra length shows most clearly. Once Ariel is on land the film spends a lot of time on discovery beats—learning to walk, tasting new food, watching people go about ordinary lives—and some of that lands with genuine charm. Bailey commits fully to the physical awkwardness without turning it into pure slapstick, and those quieter moments let the curiosity that defines the character stay front and center. Other stretches, though, feel like the movie is circling the same emotional point a few times too many. A tighter edit would have kept the momentum closer to the original’s leaner pace. The new songs sit in an odd spot. They’re not bad, and one of them gives Ariel a clearer internal voice that fits Bailey’s style, but none of them stuck with me the way the classics still do. “Under the Sea” gets a livelier, more percussive arrangement that suits Diggs, even if it drifts from the calypso bounce I grew up with. “Poor Unfortunate Souls” is McCarthy’s strongest stretch; she finds a rhythm in the number that some of her earlier dialogue scenes lack. The score underneath everything still carries Menken’s fingerprints, and the fuller orchestrations help the underwater world feel bigger without drowning the vocals. Small production choices kept pulling my attention in both directions. Light moving through water in the early sequences looks genuinely good, and most of the creature work avoids the plastic sheen that sinks other CGI-heavy remakes. On land the sets and costumes have a lived-in coastal feel rather than pure storybook gloss, which helps the two worlds feel connected. Where it slips is in a handful of close-ups on the sea creatures during heavier talk scenes—there’s a slight uncanny-valley stiffness the hand-drawn version never had to fight. Nothing ruinous, just noticeable. Jonah Hauer-King plays Eric in a lower key than some of the more exaggerated live-action princes, and that actually helps. Their connection builds through shared curiosity and small observations instead of instant destiny, so the three-day clock feels like it matters. The final act doesn’t reinvent the big set pieces, and I was glad it didn’t. The confrontation and the transformation beats still deliver the scale you want from this story, and the movie remembers to let the music and the images do a lot of the talking instead of explaining every feeling twice. I walked out thinking this is one of the better recent entries in the live-action line precisely because it doesn’t strain to justify its existence at every turn. It knows the story still works, trusts Bailey to carry the wonder, and mostly gets out of its own way. It’s longer than it needs to be and a little uneven in the villain department, but the core holds. I’d put it on again for the musical numbers and for the way the underwater world moves. Not a replacement for the 1989 film, just a solid companion piece that earns its runtime more often than it wastes it.

Report a mistake

Same rule as woke labels: one report, a written reason, and the community +1 or −1 it — once per member. A net +5 applies the change. Editors can hold it for review, or apply it immediately.

No mistake reports yet.

File a correction

Sign in to report a mistake. One report per field, per member.